Can you identify a garden weed from a perennial?
Is that the new perennial you planted last year just peeking out of the ground or a pesky weed trying to get a foothold in your garden? Could your favorite flower be reseeding, or is it a weed? It can be hard to tell! Take a look at this photo guide, and next time you go out to your garden you’ll be able to identify which plants to keep and which ones to pull.
Geum or Mugwort?
You’re working in the sunny area of your newly planted perennial border when you come across these two plants. Is it the geum (Geum hybrid) you planted last year or is it mugwort (Artemisia vulgaris)? This weed does well in disturbed areas, like a freshly dug bed, though it can work its way into established ones, too.
Both plants do best with regular moisture and well-drained soil, though mugwort seems to tolerate clay or poorer soils better than geum. Mugwort is also more cold-hardy, growing easily in USDA zone 3 while geum tops out at zone 5.
How to tell geum and mugwort apart
- Take a peek at the leaves of each plant. If the lower side is white and fuzzy, it’s mugwort.
- Geum is solid green on the top and bottom and is also slightly fuzzy.
- In addition, mugwort smells like sage when crushed.
Grecian windflower or Virginia waterleaf?
Cleaning up beds in spring, you might notice a grouping of one or both of these. Virginia waterleaf likes moist soil in light shade. But it could be some of those Grecian windflower bulbs you planted a few years ago, too.
If you’re looking for plants that naturalize for your spring garden, you might choose either of these. After all, Virginia waterleaf is native to North America. The only problem is, it tends to take over and crowd out its neighbors.
How to tell Grecian windflower and Virginia waterleaf apart
- Look for the tell-tale white spots on the leaves early, and you’ll know it’s Virginia waterleaf. They disappear by summer as the plant matures.
- Grecian windflower blooms earlier in spring than Virginia waterleaf. So if you see flower buds forming, it’s Grecian windflower.
Oriental poppy or thistle?
If you’re weeding without gloves, you might notice these plants by touch before you see them — they’re both covered in fine hairs. Which one to keep and which should you get rid of?
Pasture thistle (Cirsium discolor) is a native plant that’s quite aggressive. It prefers the disturbed soil of a garden where it’s easy to reseed, but can also muscle its way into more established situations. This thistle is a favorite of goldfinches. Oriental poppies (Papaver orientale) get pretty numerous, too, but don’t travel as far. Both plants produce rosettes of bristly foliage and have a white underside to the leaf.
How to tell Oriental poppy and thistle apart?
- Oriental poppies look bristly but don’t have spines.
- Thistles have lots of sharp spines all along the edge of the leaf and at the tip of each lobe.
Asiatic primrose or Common teasel?
Poking around the leaf litter in spring, you discover some low rosettes of foliage with wrinkled leaves. It could be your favorite primrose like this Asiatic primrose (Primula sieboldi) in the photo on the left or one of the popular Auricula types that look similar. On the other hand, common teasel (Dipsacus fullonum) might have seeded around your garden.
Both plants prefer regular moisture, though common teasel will tolerate clay soil much better than Asiatic primrose. Interesting fact: Teasel’s seedheads are sometimes used in dried floral arrangements (although you probably don’t want it to go to seed in your own garden!).
How to tell Asiatic primrose and commong teasel apart?
- Carefully check out the underside of the leaves. Common teasel has small spines along its white center vein.
Butterfly weed or horseweed?
If you suddenly notice there’s a stand of butterfly weed (Asclepias tuberosa) where there wasn’t before, don’t get too excited. It might be fast-growing horseweed (Conyza canadensis) instead of slow-growing butterfly weed.
Good soil and lots of sun will benefit these two plants. They’re both quite drought-tolerant and can even grow in fast-draining poor soil, but clay soil is another matter. Horseweed will still do just fine, but butterfly weed will eventually die.
How to tell butterfly weed and horseweed apart
- Take a close look at the leaves. Horseweed leaves will have a few teeth toward their tips.
- Horseweed has a bitter odor when crushed.
Jacob’s ladder or crown vetch
Is there a spot in your garden that stays moist most of the growing season? That makes it a good place to grow Jacob’s ladder (Polemonium caeruleum), but crown vetch (Securigera varia) might happily take hold there, as well.
Crown vetch is an import that’s naturalized in all but four states and most of southern Canada. It tolerates a lot of harsh conditions but truly thrives with regular moisture, just like Jacob’s ladder. And with those small leaves growing directly across from each other, it’s hard to tell them apart.
How to tell Jacob’s ladder and crown vetch apart
- Is the plant growing in full shade? Then it’s probably not crown vetch. This weed prefers sunny sites although it might creep into areas of part shade.
- Jacob’s ladder grows best in full to part shade.
- Crown vetch has a rhizome.
- Jacob’s ladder has fibrous roots.
Purple coneflower or white campion?
Your full sun border has a nice stand of purple coneflowers (Echinacea purpurea) but you notice a few leaves that don’t look quite right — it could be (Silene pratensis) white campion.
Full sun borders and open meadows are the perfect setting for natives like purple coneflower. Unfortunately, that’s just what white campion likes, too. It’s naturalized through most of North America; so much so that it’s sometimes listed as a wildflower. But it’s quite aggressive in cultivated areas like a garden.
How to tell purple coneflower and white campion apart
- If you start to see flower stems in spring, it’s probably white campion. It’s done blooming by mid-May.
- White campion leaves are smooth-edged and egg-shaped.
- Purple coneflower has pointed leaves, which may also have a slightly toothed edge.
Hollyhock or garlic mustard?
That sunny bed where your hollyhocks (Alcea rosea) grow is also just the place garlic mustard (Alliaria petiolata) loves. This noxious weed emerges with a low rosette of leaves that can mimic that of your favorite biennial.
Though hollyhock grows as a perennial in mild climates, for most gardeners in USDA cold-hardiness zones 2 to 10 it acts as a biennial, self-seeding and flowering the second year. So does garlic mustard. Each of these weed plants produces thousands of seeds that can travel by wind, on animal fur or clothing. Not only do the weed’s rosettes emerge at the same time as the hollyhock’s, they’re dead ringers! Now what?
How to tell hollyhock and garlic mustard apart
- Garlic mustard is easy to tell from your hollyhocks — just crush a leaf. As the name suggests, if it smells like garlic, pull it.
Globe thistle or milk thistle
Perhaps you already know your globe thistle grows happily in full sun and lean or poor soil. But a look-alike may be elbowing its way into this same spot!
Globe thistle is cold-hardy in USDA zones 3 to 8. The weed milk thistle, its spitting image, is common throughout North America, and both reseed readily. So how do you know which one’s sprouting in your garden?
How to tell globe thistle and milk thistle apart
- Milk thistle has green hairless leaves with white veins. And once the leaves start to stretch, they look shiny.
- Globe thistle has woolly leaves.
Astilbe or sweet cicely?
I love my classic shade-loving astilbes. Preferring humus-rich, moist soil and part to full shade, they tolerate sun if I keep them consistently moist. Sweet cicely is a weed that thrives in exactly the same conditions. I had to do a double-take when I found it growing shoulder to shoulder with my astilbes!
Both plants prefer moist areas in USDA cold zones 4 to 8. But you’re more likely to see sweet cicely, which readily spreads by seeds, where winters are cold and snowy. (The seeds need this cold stratification to germinate.) Astilbe doesn’t tend to reseed, so if you see a plant sprouting, it’s probably not your astilbe.
How to tell astilble and sweet cicely apart
- Astilbe leaves are sharply toothed.
- The edges of sweet cicely are much more rounded.
- In early spring, most astilbe stems are darker colored than sweet cicely, too.
Bachelor’s button or mullein?
Oh look, your perennial bachelor’s button has reseeded itself in a new spot in the garden! Or is that a mullein seed that’s taken root and sprouted?
Seedlings of both of these plants will sprout in sunny spots, though perennial bachelor’s button, which is cold-hardy in USDA zones 3 to 8, spreads by stolons, as well as by seeds. Mullein produces yellow flowers on 5- to 6-ft. stems in summer; perennial bachelor’s button’s late spring blue flowers top out at 12 to 24 in. tall.
How to tell bachelor’s button and mullein apart
- With their soft, hairy gray-green leaves, the young plants look very similar, but there’s an easy tell: Look under the leaves — mulleins have very prominent veins, perennial bachelor’s buttons don’t.
There you have it. You can step into your garden with your weeding tools and a load of confidence now that identifying weeds from perennials has been demystified.